History of All-Americans
1978
- Marc Glardino 1st team
- Rich Law 1st team
- Mike Hathaway 2nd team
1982
- Fredrick Douglas Opie 1st team
- Matt Kleehammer 2nd team
- Bryan Polmanteer 1st team
1983
- Fredrick Douglas Opie 1st team, Syracuse University, Herkimer Generals H.O.F., NJCAA H.O.F.
- William Barth 1st team, RIT
- Jack Beaney 1st Team, Cornell
- Rob Bromley 2nd team
1984
- Joe Colarusso 1st team
- Neil Braman 2nd team
1985
- Ron Knox 1st team, Washington College
- John Niven 1st team, Ithaca
- Bob Quinn 1st team, Penn State
- Rob Randall 1st team, Nazareth
- Tim Cronin 2nd team, RIT
- Bernard Marino 2nd team, Delaware
1986
- Michael Falvey 1stteam
- William Herger Jr 1st team
- Thomas Kraft 1stteam
- Robert Kuzdzal 2nd team
1987
- Dan Caughey 1st Team, Syracuse University
- Darrin McCormick 2nd team
1988 National Champions
- Gregory Boyce 1st team, Cornell
- Jerry Farrell 1st team, St. John's
- Mike LaCrosse 1st team, Hofstra
- Thomas Quinn 1st team
- David Reilly 1st team
- David Sizing 2nd team, Clarkson
- Eric Ungleich 2nd team, Salisbury
1989 National Champions
- John Hill 1st team, RPI
- Tom Reisinger 1st team
- Mark McNerny 1st team, Junior College Player of the Year
- Rich Barnes 1st team, Cortland State
- Mike Macgrane 2nd team, University of Virginia
- Mike Motkowski 2nd team, Ohio State
1990
- Joe Borges 1st team, Rutgers
- Dan Kesseiring 1st team
- Gary Falor 2nd team
1991
- Steve Carcaterra 1stteam, Towson
- Regy Thorpe 1st team, Syracuse University
- Jeff Roos 1st team
- Mike Tesoriero 2nd team University of Albany
1992 National Champions
- Thad Boyce 1st team, Delaware
- Gary Cegielski 1st team, Adelphi
- Joe Gloeckener 1st team, Butler
- Brad Nelson 1st team, Ithaca
1993 National Champions
- Alex Rosier 1st team, Syracuse University, NJCAA Lacrosse H.O.F.
- Michael Joyce 1st team, Delware
- Eric Merkel 1st team, Penn State
- David Signor 1st team, Syracuse University
- Jared SMith 1st team, Springfield College
- Pete Colburn 2nd team, Alfred
- Vincent Dello 2nd team
1994 National Champions
- Chris Theofiled 1st team, Stonybrook
- David Carmen 1st team
- Lee Williams 1st team
- A.J. Arland 2nd team
- Justin Nels 2nd team
1995 National Champions
- Dan Brennan 1st team, Georgetown
- Charlie Flaherty 1st team, Adelphi
- Dan Garrett 1stteam, Nazareth
- David Mohoskey 1st team, Loyola
- Anthony Tufano 1st team
- Adam Wor 2nd team
1996 National Champions
- Matt Bregande 1st team
- Brian McDonlad 1st team
- Mike Monroe 2nd team, RPI
- Brian Smiley 2nd team
1997
- Mike Villano 1st team, Hobart
- Todd Kaiser 1st team, Penn State
- Eric Capello 1st team
- Joe Driscoll 2nd team, John Hopkins University
- Marc Reeves 2nd team, Adelphi
1998
- Sam Bassett 1st team, Syracuse University
- Luke Leonard 1st team, Denver
- Chris Coyne 1st team, Syracuse University
- Andy Mulligan, 1st team, Towson
- Colin Nels 1stteam
- Trevor Harvey 2nd team
- Dylan Levy 2ndteam
- Jay Sothoron 2nd team
1999
- Rich Dommer 1st team, Adelphi
- Jim Barnes 1st team, Salisbury
2000
- Jordan Vettoretti 1st team, Junior College Player of the Year, Georgetown University
2001
- Brandon Seneca 2nd team
2002
- Rodney Redeye 1st team
- Delby Powless 1st team, Rutgers University
- Ron Cogan 1st team
- Matt Holdridge 2nd team, LeMoyne College
2003 NAtional Champions
- Scott Ditzell 1st team, Junior College Player of the Year, Syracuse University
- Roger Vyse 1st team, Limestone College
- Corey Warner 1st team, UMBC
- Dave Kemp 2nd team, Mars Hill
2004
- Jamie Ireland 1st team, Junior Colleg Player of the Year, Syracuse University
- Dan Carey 2nd team, Canisius
- Mike Bringley 2nd team, Mercyhurst
2005 National Champions
- Brett Queener 1st team, University of Albany
- Adam Zuder-Havens 1st team, University of Delaware
- Brandon Butler 2nd team, Adelphi
- Todd Olson 2ndteam, Cornell
2006
- Eddie Ege 1stteam
- Hans Van Houten 1st team
- Mike Ball 2nd team
2007
- Dave Brock 2nd team
- Sean Doyle 2nd team
- Thomas Maher 2nd team
2008
- Zach Bates 1st team
- Dave Brock 2nd team, University of Albany, Buffalo Bandits of NLL
2009
- JP Finn 1st team
- Doug Hoch 2nd team
- Dan Solazzo 2nd team
- Justin Hayes 1st team, Ohio State
- Kevin Kemp 1st eam, Aldephi